Pages

motto

“When Israel, the only country in the world whose very existence is under attack, is consistently and conspicuously singled out for condemnation, I believe we are morally obligated to take a stand.” by Canada's PM Harper

Saturday, 21 November 2026

After elections - why is it so hard to make a new Israeli government

 I am by no means an expert on domestic Israeli politics. The situation is complex - as it is in any country - and has recently been exceptionally unfavorable to moderate voters and stability. This is evidenced by a series of five elections in less than four years (between 2019 and 2022), which occurred because it proved impossible to form a stable government (under normal circumstances, elections should take place every four years). It was precisely this inability to form a stable coalition and government that determined the course of the subsequent years, during which Benjamin Netanyahu served as Prime Minister. By 2019, there was already immense fatigue with his leadership; yet, the electoral marathon, combined with the intricacies of election arithmetic, secured him further years in the prime minister’s chair.

Some might argue that this is a case in favor of single-member districts and a two-party system. I disagree; however - setting aside the fact that this is not the place to debate the merits and drawbacks of two-party versus multi-party systems (a subject on which many books have been written) - a two-party system is simply not feasible in Israel. This is due not to electoral legislation, but to demographics (and history). And that is precisely what I will discuss below.

Most countries in today’s world are deeply polarized - politically, socially, and in terms of cultural values. Israel is no exception, but in its case, additional divisions come into play:

1. Ethnic: 20% of Israel’s population are Arabs. In addition, there are Druze, Circassians, and Bedouins. Bedouins and Druze serve in the military. Among the Arab population, a significant proportion of Christians serve, as do around 10-15% of Muslims (mostly women, for whom it serves as an opportunity for emancipation). This service is voluntary.

2. Religious: among Arabs, primarily into Christians and Muslims; among Jews, into Orthodox, traditional, Reform, and secular.

3. A separate, large group consists of the Haredim - currently accounting for about 14.5% of the population - with whom there is a bitter dispute regarding military service.

On top of this, there is a war that has been ongoing for three years without interruption.

And all of this exists beyond the usual polarization. 

The electoral system is proportional, with a 3.25% threshold.  

Furthermore, this is a country where people constantly discuss - and argue about - politics. 

The secular, staunchly right-wing Likud party has spent the last few years in a coalition with Haredi (ultra-Orthodox) parties; however, even the United Torah Judaism alliance has withheld its support for Netanyahu as prime minister, arguing that he failed to do enough to protect the status of yeshiva students - specifically their exemption from military conscription.

While left-leaning parties might theoretically form a government with Arab parties - as has been attempted in the past - three years after the Hamas attack, doing so remains extremely difficult, if not practically impossible. Everyone is at an impasse. It is likely that no other democracy would be able to handle this, either - though that is little consolation.


 


No comments:

Post a Comment